Is unusual options activity a sign of insider trading?

By Faizan Ahmad. Updated .

Rarely, and the flow almost never tells you which trade it is. The SEC regularly charges people who bought options, usually cheap, short-dated out-of-the-money calls, days before a takeover or other big announcement, and research finds abnormal options volume ahead of about a quarter of takeovers. But the vast majority of unusual options activity is hedging, spreads, rolls and ordinary bets on public information, placed by institutions with no secret at all.

What does insider trading in options look like?

SEC cases follow a remarkably consistent pattern. Three examples from the SEC's own releases:

CaseWhat was boughtTimingOutcome
Semrush (settled May 22, 2026)Out-of-the-money Semrush calls, among other bullish trades, by a man whose spouse worked on Adobe's M&A teamNovember 8 to 18, 2025, before Adobe's November 19 deal announcement; Semrush rose 74%$1,317,233 profit; paid $1,975,850 in disgorgement and penalty, without admitting or denying the findings
Pfizer (charged June 29, 2023)Short-term out-of-the-money Pfizer calls, some expiring the next day, allegedly bought by an employee on the Paxlovid trialNovember 4, 2021, the day before positive trial resultsAlleged one-day return of 2,458%
ADT (charged April 14, 2016)Thousands of out-of-the-money ADT calls, allegedly bought by a research analyst in his mother's accountBefore Apollo's acquisition of ADT was announcedMore than $1.5M in alleged profit

The shared profile: out-of-the-money calls, short expiries, a specific event days away, and a quick sale right after the news. Options appeal to someone with a secret because a small amount of cash can multiply many times if the news lands, which is exactly what that 2,458% figure shows (more on the appeal in why anyone buys far out-of-the-money calls).

How common is it?

A study by Patrick Augustin, Menachem Brenner and Marti Subrahmanyam, published in Management Science in 2019, looked at options trading before 1,859 US takeovers announced from 1996 to 2012. About 25% of the deals had abnormal options volume beforehand, concentrated in short-dated, out-of-the-money calls, and the authors argue more than half of that activity is hard to explain with speculation, rumors or deal predictability. They also note the SEC litigated only about 8% of the deals in their sample.

Read that carefully. It says suspicious options volume shows up before a good share of takeovers. It does not say unusual options volume usually means a takeover is coming. Takeovers are rare; unusual trades show up every trading day.

Why most unusual activity is not insider trading

Compare the SEC pattern with the standout trades on an ordinary day. On October 30, 2026, the unusual bets (size bigger than open interest) looked like this:

SEC insider casesUnusual bets on October 30, 2026
ExpiryDays or weeks; some expired the next dayMostly months or years: Meta February 2027, Amazon September 2027, AMD December 2028
StrikeOut of the moneyOften in the money: Citigroup $72.50 and $75 calls at about $46 to $49 a share
CompanyA takeover target or pending newsGiants like Meta, Alphabet, Amazon and Citigroup
SideCalls boughtA mix, including puts sold at the bid in Seagate and Alphabet
MoneyAlleged profits from about $60,000 to more than $1.5M$6.55M to $24.82M of premium per trade

Large, long-dated, in the money and two-sided is what institutions hedging, rebalancing and expressing views look like. Index options tell the same story: that day they carried a put/call ratio by premium of 1.26, against 0.91 for single stocks, because index puts are where portfolios get insured.

Is it legal to trade on unusual options activity you see?

Yes. Options flow is public market data: every trade is published on OPRA, the consolidated options tape. What the SEC prosecutes is trading on material nonpublic information in breach of a duty to keep it confidential, charged under Section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act and Rule 10b-5, as in each case above. Seeing a big print and trading the same contract is acting on public information.

What should you do when flow looks suspicious?

How Tradytics shows this

Tradytics reads the full OPRA tape: every trade on every US options exchange, live, about a second after it prints, stitched into orders and tagged as bought or sold from its price against the quote. On the Live options flow page you can type what you want to see in plain English, such as "short-dated out-of-the-money calls bought at the ask, bigger than open interest", and save it as a view: the profile the SEC cases share. Every session since January 3, 2022, more than 50 million orders, is available through the API, so you can look back at what traded before any announcement. Each stock's options research page (Plus and Pro), such as AMD's, lists its largest and unusual orders with size next to open interest. What makes an options trade unusual explains each test.

On Tradytics: clean options flow from the full tape, Signals from a study of 560 million pattern and horizon combinations, and every order since January 3, 2022 in the options flow API and the backtester.

Common questions

How does the SEC catch insider trading in options?

Through surveillance. In the Pfizer case, the SEC said the investigation came from its Market Abuse Unit's Analysis and Detection Center, which uses data analysis tools to detect suspicious trading patterns.

Is buying calls before earnings insider trading?

Not unless the trader has material nonpublic information and a duty not to use it. Positioning before a scheduled report on public information is ordinary speculation.

Does unusual call buying mean a buyout is coming?

Almost never on its own. Takeovers are rare and unusual call buying is common, so most of it is followed by no deal at all.

Can insider trading show up in puts?

Yes. Bad news can be traded with puts the same way. The three cases above happen to involve calls before good news.

Sources