Tradytics vs Trade Ideas
By Faizan Ahmad. Updated .
Trade Ideas can't show you the options tape, dark pool prints, dealer exposure, an options fund run entirely by AI, Kalshi and Polymarket odds, a backtest on options, or a payoff chart on the options you hold, and it has no data API, MCP server or native app. Tradytics has all of them: the full OPRA tape stitched into about 58,000 orders a session, every dark pool block print ranked against the stock's own last 12 months, the Tradytics AI Fund, Signals from a study of 560 million pattern and horizon combinations, Probabilities on 5.95 million Kalshi and Polymarket markets, a backtester that fills options at the real bid and ask, payoff charts on your own broker positions, custom dashboards from 56 widgets, and one API and MCP server on every plan. Plus is $39 a month against $127 for TI Standard and $254 for TI Premium. Trade Ideas' strength is intraday stock scanning, with Holly AI signals and auto trading.
Tradytics and Trade Ideas, feature by feature
Trade Ideas' side is from its own pricing, features and review pages, checked November 5, 2026.
| Tradytics | Trade Ideas | |
|---|---|---|
| Options flow | The full OPRA tape, live, stitched into orders tagged bought or sold, noise filtered out: about 58,000 a session; every session since January 3, 2022 (more than 50 million orders) | An unusual options activity channel; it covers US stocks |
| Dark pool prints | Every block print ranked against the stock's own last 12 months; block and auction history since January 2022 | None |
| Dealer exposure | Gamma, delta, vanna and charm for about 2,500 stocks every 5 minutes; 0DTE gamma every 30 seconds | None |
| Flow signals | Signals: seven flow patterns from a study of 560 million pattern and horizon combinations, each tracked to expiry | Holly AI stock signals, backtested nightly; no full published track record |
| AI-run fund | The Tradytics AI Fund: a long/short options fund managed entirely by AI, every trade published | None; Money Machine places no live orders |
| Prediction markets | Kalshi and Polymarket; 5.95 million markets since 2021, settled ones included | None (a blog article only) |
| Backtester | Plain words, on stocks, real option quotes, options flow, dark pool prints and Kalshi and Polymarket | OddsMaker: any alert over the last 60 days on 1-minute bars, stocks only, no bid-ask spread |
| Your own portfolio | Read-only broker link, a payoff chart on every option held, Factors and Versus | Order management with P&L through IBKR, E*TRADE, TradeStation and Alpaca; no payoff charts |
| Custom dashboards | 56 widgets, every plan | Windows desktop layouts of scans, charts and lists; web dashboards fixed |
| AI analyst | An agent that pulls flow, dark pool and dealer data itself; 3, 20 or unlimited questions a day | AI Assistant builds scans from plain English, both paid plans |
| API | Free: 50 calls a day, 5 a minute; Plus: 5,000 a day, 50 a minute; Pro: 50,000 a day, 300 a minute. Per account. Flow since January 2022 | None; broker connections only |
| MCP server | Yes, on every plan, every dataset as a tool | None |
| Mobile | Native iOS app, plus the web app on any device | No native app; web dashboards in a phone browser |
| Price | Free; Plus $39 a month or $299 a year; Pro $69 or $499 a year | TI Free (delayed web dashboards); TI Standard $127 and TI Premium $254 a month ($1,068 and $2,136 a year) |
Where Tradytics is ahead
- The options tape. Clean options flow reads every trade on every US options exchange, stitches the fills into about 58,000 orders a session and tags each as bought or sold.
- Signals with the study published. Signals come from seven flow patterns found by testing 560 million combinations on 10.9 million prints, and every signal is the contract the flow bought, tracked every 5 minutes to expiry. Trade Ideas shows "selected examples" of Holly's signals.
- An options fund run entirely by AI. The Tradytics AI Fund holds calls, puts and spreads long and short, and publishes every trade, exit and a weekly letter.
- Backtests on options. The backtester fills options at the real bid and ask from March 2022, with stock data since 2003, flow, dark pool prints and prediction markets. OddsMaker covers 60 days of stocks.
- Ranked dark pool and dealer exposure. Every block print ranked against its stock's year, and gamma, delta, vanna and charm for about 2,500 stocks every 5 minutes.
- Prediction markets. Probabilities charts every live finance question on Kalshi and Polymarket, on 5.95 million markets back to 2021.
- Your options and your data. Payoff charts on the options you hold, dashboards from 56 widgets in any browser, and an API and MCP server on every plan.
What options flow shows that a stock scanner can't: a real example
On October 30, 2026, Citi (C) fell 2.6%, the kind of move any stock scanner flags. The options tape showed something else: at 3:18 PM ET, 5,350 of the December 18 $75 calls were bought at the ask for $24.82M against open interest of just 2,675. By the close, Citi was the market's most bullish name by net premium, $93.80M, on a red day. A price-and-volume scanner never sees that. More in how to tell opening from closing trades.

What Trade Ideas does well
- Intraday stock scanning. Holly AI re-tests its strategy bank every night and fires only the ones that make the cut the next session.
- Auto trading at your broker. Run your own rules at IBKR, E*TRADE, TradeStation and Alpaca.
- Desktop layouts. Free-floating windows, multi-monitor, 20+ templates and up to 20 charts on Premium.
- Plain-English scans. The AI Assistant turns a sentence into a scan that feeds OddsMaker.
Bottom line
Choose Tradytics if you trade options or want the money behind a stock: the full tape, ranked dark pool, dealer exposure, the AI Fund, Signals, Probabilities, backtests on real option quotes and payoff charts on your own positions, for $39 a month, with the API and MCP server free, with higher limits on the $69 Pro plan. Trade Ideas fits stock day traders who want Holly's signals and auto trading on a Windows desktop, from $127 a month. See how the Tradytics scanner works or compare Tradytics vs TrendSpider.
Common questions
Does Trade Ideas have options flow?
Only an unusual options activity channel; it covers US stocks and lists no dark pool or dealer exposure. Tradytics reads the full OPRA tape live from $39 a month.
How do Holly AI and Tradytics Signals differ?
Holly gives stock entries and stops from strategies re-tested nightly, with selected examples shown. Tradytics Signals are the calls and puts live orders bought when they matched a pattern from a 560 million combination study, each tracked to expiry.
Can I backtest options on Trade Ideas?
No. OddsMaker tests stock alerts over the last 60 days on 1-minute bars without the bid-ask spread. Tradytics fills options at the real bid and ask from March 2022.
Does Trade Ideas have an app?
No native app; TI Pro runs on Windows, and the web dashboards run in a phone browser. Tradytics has a native iOS app, plus the web app on any device.
Can I place trades from Tradytics?
No. The broker link is read only: it tracks holdings, trades and P&L on the portfolio page and charts the payoff of every option you hold.
Sources
- Trade Ideas pricing: TI Free, Standard and Premium prices, OddsMaker, broker connections, desktop layouts, the AI Assistant.
- Trade Ideas AI signals: Holly's nightly backtests, selected examples, unusual options activity.
- Trade Ideas Money Machine: no live orders.
- Trade Ideas review page: US stocks coverage, OddsMaker limits, Windows desktop app.
- Tradytics on the App Store: the native iOS app.
- OPRA: the consolidated options tape Tradytics' flow is built on.